Here is the prisoner’s dilemma.
When you cloud the title of a short sale with the Notice of Option and your C buyer goes behind your back (after signing a contract with you for $10,000 more than you owe the Seller A) to Seller A and creates their own deal, cutting you completely out of the deal, do you show up at closing?
Here’s the rest of the story.
We knew C had gone to A because A called B and was furious. You’re making $10,000 on my house! How could you do that and not give me any of the money?
C had proven to be a sneaky snake oil salesman. And he painted the picture that B, the investor, was really the sneaky snake oil salesman and A believed it. When in fact, B was the only one doing what the Option paperwork and subsequent Purchase Contract to C said she would do.
- Buy the property,
- Find another buyer,
- Resell the property and
- Make her money on the spread.
The investor had spent months working on this transaction only to be left out in the cold at the end. She did need to close by the end of the month to meet the banks’ requirements. She would have made it too but C went to A, took more time, C decided he could negotiate better with the bank and get an extension into the following month, making up a story to A and forcing B to back out.
B did however, send an acceptance letter to the attorney who was to close the now A to C purchase that she would uncloud the title for $5,000. – release her Notice of Option. Just 1/2 of what she would have made had everybody done what they originally agreed to.
A mistakening sent an email to B (which was meant for the closing attorney) saying she felt sure B would “get out of the way with a payment of only $2,000. Just tell her to show up at 4:30p.m. she’ll show up and take it, we don’t have to pay her $5,000″.
I’ll publish the results of the survey here in a few weeks.

Recent Comments